- There has been an extraordinary flight to safety within European equities over the last 12 months, but it has occurred without fanfare.
- This level of risk aversion is normally associated with a very high VIX index and near panic.
- This time it has occurred more slowly, with little comment.
This level of risk aversion can best be measured by the relative valuation of “strong defensives” vs “weak cyclicals” within European equities. In this case I am using the valuation of European consumer staples companies ** compared to the European banks index. Below we show the ratio of relative valuation in price to sales and price to book terms since 2003.
Historically, this degree of risk aversion has been followed by sharp degrees of outperformance for banks over staples, for value over growth and also the outperformance of European equities over US equities. The premium paid for defensiveness has only ever been this high twice before. In the summer of 2012 at the height of the Sovereign Debt Crisis and in late June 2016 in the days after Brexit.
Starting in the summer of 2012 banks outperformed staples by 100% in the following 22 months. After June 2016 banks outperformed by 55% in the following 15 months. European equities also outperformed US equities by double digit percentages in both cases in the following 12-18 months.
What is the cause of this valuation extreme?
The market is nervous that the European economy is slowing, and rightly considering that the existing monetary policy tool kit is exhausted. Today investors are not only pricing in a potential recession, but also one that may not end.
Why the absence of fanfare?
The absence of comment about this incredible valuation divergence may be the most important element. Part of the reason must reflect positioning. But there is also likely some behavioural psychology at work. Elizabeth Kübler-Ross’ five stages of grief can sometimes be helpful in identifying the psychology involved at the end of bear markets. Denial, Anger, Bargaining, Depression and Acceptance. It seems with European banks the market is at the acceptance stage. Valuations are going lower, discounts are getting wider, and it is attracting little interest or commentary. “This is just how it is”. Staples become more expensive, banks become cheaper, with no questions asked. We believe these are the conditions of major turning points.
What is the catalyst?
With valuations this extreme, it is fair to say that no catalyst is needed. Banks are now paying nearly 7% yields and are growing earnings c.5% per year at trough margins. From this perspective we are paid to wait. But investors are too negative about policy. Whilst European rate cuts cannot help and may even prove harmful, there is still one major policy tool left for Europe that should not be underestimated: fiscal stimulus backed by monetary policy. Whilst the political architecture is not yet in place to allow this today, it could be soon. This will mechanically lift growth, lift inflation and have the opposite impact on the yield curve that investors are used to. All monetary policy stimulus to date has flattened the yield curve, fiscal stimulus backed by monetary policy will steepen it.
We anticipate a very sharp snap back in favour of value over growth, of banks over staples, and quite likely, European equities over US equities over the coming twelve months.
Nestle, Unilever, Pernod Ricard, L’Oreal
This communication and its content are owned by Lightman Investment Management Limited (“Lightman”, “we”, “us”). Lightman Investment Management Limited (FRN: 827120) is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (“FCA”) as a UK MiFID portfolio manager eligible to deal with professional clients and eligible counterparties in the UK. Lightman is registered with Companies House in England and Wales under the registration number 11647387, having its registered office at c/o Buzzacott LLP, 130 Wood Street, London, United Kingdom, EC2V 6DL.
This communication is intended for ‘Eligible Counterparties’ and ‘Professional’ clients only, as described under the UK Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 (“FSMA”) (and any amendments to it). It is not intended for ‘Retail’ clients and Lightman does not have permission to provide investment services to retail clients. Generally, marketing communications are only intended for ‘Eligible Counterparties’ and ‘Professional’ clients in the UK, unless they are being used for purposes other than marketing, such as regulations and compliance etc. The Firm may produce marketing or communication documents for selected investor types in non UK jurisdictions. Such documents would clearly state the target audience and target jurisdiction.
Collective Investment Scheme(s)
The collective investment scheme(s) – WS Lightman Investment Funds (PRN: 838695) (“UK OEIC”, “UK umbrella”), and WS Lightman European Fund (PRN: 838696) (“UK sub-fund”, “UK product”) are regulated collective scheme(s), authorised and regulated by the FCA. In accordance with Section 238 of FSMA, such schemes can be marketed to the UK general public. Lightman, however, does not intend to receive subscription or redemption orders from retail clients and accordingly such retail clients should either contact their investment adviser or the Management Company Waystone Management (UK) Limited (“Waystone UK”) in relation to any fund documents.
The collective investment scheme(s) - Elevation Fund SICAV (Code: O00012482) (“Luxembourg SICAV”, “Luxembourg umbrella”), and Lightman European Equities Fund (Code: O00012482_00000002) (“Luxembourg sub-fund”, “Lux product”) are regulated undertakings for collective investments in transferrable securities (UCITS), authorised and regulated by the Commission de Surveillance du Secteur Financier (CSSF) in Luxembourg. In accordance with regulatory approvals obtained under the requirements of the Law of 17 December 2010 relating to undertakings for collective investment, the schemes can be marketed to the public in Luxembourg, Norway, Spain, and Republic of Ireland. Lightman, however, does not intend to receive subscription or redemption orders from any client types for the Lux product and accordingly such client should either contact a domestic distributor, domestic investment advisor or the Management Company Link Fund Solutions (Luxembourg) S.A. (“Link Luxembourg”) in relation to any fund documents.
Luxembourg umbrella and Luxembourg sub-fund are also approved for marketing to professional clients and eligible counterparties in the UK under the UK National Private Placement Regime (NPPR). UK registration numbers for the funds are as follows: Elevation Fund SICAV (PRN: 957838) and Lightman European Equities Fund (PRN: 957839). Please write to us at email@example.com for proof of UK registration of the funds.
Luxembourg sub-fund is also approved for marketing to qualified investors in Switzerland, within the meaning of Art. 10 para. 3 and 3ter CISA. In Switzerland, the representative is Acolin Fund Services AG, Leutschenbachstrasse 50, 8050 Zurich, Switzerland, whilst the paying agent is NPB Neue Privat Bank AG, Limmatquai 1 / am Bellevue, 8024 Zurich, Switzerland.
Accuracy and correctness of information
Lightman takes all reasonable steps to ensure the accuracy and completeness of its communications; we however request all recipients to contact us directly for the latest information and documents as issued documents may not be fully updated. We cannot accept any liability arising from loss or damage from the use of this communication.
Wherever our communications refer to a third party such as Waystone, Link, Northern Trust etc., we cannot accept any responsibility for the availability of their services or the accuracy and correctness of their content. We urge users to contact the third party for any query related to their services.
Important information for non-UK persons (Including US persons)
This communication is not intended for any person outside of the UK, Switzerland, or the European Economic Area (EEA). Lightman or any of the funds referenced in this communication are not approved for marketing outside of the UK, Switzerland, or the EEA. All such persons must consult their domestic lawyers in relation to services or products offered by Lightman.
Risk warning to all investors
The value of investments in any financial assets may fall as well as rise. Investors may not get back the amount they originally invested. Past performance is not an indicator of future performance. Potential investors should not use this communication as the basis of an investment decision. Decisions to invest in any fund should be taken only on the basis of information available in the latest fund documents. Potential investors should carefully consider the risks described in those documents and, if required, consult a financial adviser before deciding to invest.
Offer, advice, or recommendation
No information in this communication is intended to act as an offer, investment advice or recommendation to buy or sell a product or to engage in investment services or activities. You must consult your investment adviser or a lawyer before engaging in any investment service or product.
This communication cannot be distributed or reproduced without our consent.